Home Decorators...cheap or chic?

I just flipped through the latest Home Decorators Collection catalog and I must admit that there were a few pieces that caught my eye. In the past, their merch looked a bit tacky and cheap, but it seems that things at HDC have improved lately...at least in terms of style. On their website they have an overwhelming amount of stuff...from furniture to bathroom vanities to holiday goods. I tried to wade through most of it, but there is probably still more ground to cover. In any case, here are my picks:

Camel-Back Parsons Chair with Nailhead Trim - $249

Clara Table Lamp - $59

Martha Stewart Living Ingrid Buffet - $749

Tufted-Back Dining Chair - $249

Juliette Area Rug - $39 (Really it's a kitchen mat)

Claiborne 3-Light Pendant - $249

Holbrook Dining Table - $799

Sandra Counter Stool - $149

Martha Stewart Living Ingrid Desk - $499

Oxford File Cabinet - $149

Reflections Mirrored Three-Piece Cabinet Set - $599

Have you ordered anything from there? If so, I'd love to hear about the quality. My expectations for quality are always relative to price, and their items are in that zone where the wood finishes and fabric options might not be good enough to justify the deal. Please speak up if you know from experience!

Also, I know that Overstock and SmartBargains often have the same (or similar) merch for cheaper prices, so be sure to cross-reference those sites before you buy from HDC!